Midwifery Profession: Pros And Cons

The Free essays given on our site were donated by anonymous users and should not be viewed as samples of our custom writing service. You are welcome to use them to inspire yourself for writing your own term paper. If you need a custom term paper related to the subject of Gynecology or Midwifery Profession: Pros And Cons , you can hire a professional writer here in just a few clicks.
Support for the Midwifery Profession: Pros and Cons The tradition of midwifery virtually disappeared in Canada during the early part of this century. Several generations of women gave up childbirth at home to the medical profession. They did this in the name of safety and pain relief, or simply because the option of being cared for by a midwife no longer existed. Midwifery should be re-instated as a legal and honourable profession. With healthy pregnancies and under normal conditions, women should give birth at home with the professional assistance of a midwife. The most common argument against home births and midwifery are perpetuated by the medical establishment. As a profession, they openly oppose to lay midwifery, and as Dr. William Hall, president of the College of Physicians, said, he and the college oppose home births because they feel it is unsafe. (Ramondt, 1990) Undoubtedly, the medical profession is correct in protesting home births in certain cases. Some pregnancies are difficult and some births are problematic. It is not difficult to concede that there are times when sound medical intervention is a necessity and a blessing. To insist, though, that every birth requires a hospital setting and the attendance of a doctor with ten years training is, as many experts in the field agree, rather ludicrous. A study done by Dr. Lewis Mehl (cited in Barringtonm, 1985), matched a population of 421 women attended by physicians with 421 women attended by midwifes at home. The midwife sample fared far better with significantly less fetal distress, birth injuries, and infants needing resuscitation. The former head of the International Confederation of Gynecology & Obstetrics, Dr. Caldero Barcia, goes as far to state that, "iatrogenia (doctor-caused illness) is the main cause of fetal distress" (Barrington, 1985, p. 122). Furthermore, the routine of use of medical procedures initially developed to protect high-risk mothers and babies are often used by doctors simply as preventive measures. An episiotomy (cutting the perineum) is done in 80% of hospital births. Midwives use it less than 1% of the time. Labour is induced 40% of the time in hospitals; whereas, midwives never induce births. Cesarean sections are performed in 16.3% of hospital births while they rate for midwifery is only 307% (Hopkins, 1990). Some doctors will argue the comparison of the rates ignores the reality that hospitals deal with most of the high-risk births. According to Dr. Malcolm Brown, a health care economist at the University of Calgary, however, the high rate of cesareans done in hospitals is because, "doctors find it convenient and they make money on them" (Ramondt, 1990). Physicians also collect extra fees for inducing labour and for giving spinal blocks. These realities make it questionable whether or not to use these procedures are used in only high-risk situations as originally intended. As well, giving birth at home offers parents and opportunity that hospitals cannot give. At home they are free to create an atmosphere of their own choosing for the birth. These greatly increase the chance for both parents to have a meaningful and personal experience. There is comfort and convenience in having the midwife come to them in surroundings that are familiar and emotionally safe. Eleanor Barrington (1985) states that studies suggest that a mother's biting experience relates to the baby's motor and cognitive development at two and six months of age (p. 122). Feeling good about the birth experience would appear to enhance the mother/child relationship and, consequently, the child's development. This is a consideration that midwives take seriously and is reflected in the quality of care and support that they offer throughout the entire experience. Finally, a home birth presided over by a midwife is, in the long run, less costly. Alberta Health Care pays physicians $284 for a delivery. This does not include costs for hospitalization, pre- or post-natal care, or any additional costs that may arise out of inducement of labour, cesareans, spinal blocks, or other services. The cost for an average hospital bed per night is $450. With the average stay for a birth being three to seven days, the cost

Our inspirational collection of essays and research papers is available for free to our registered users

Related Essays on Gynecology

The Effects Of Tetracycline On Chick Embryos

THE EFFECTS OF TETRACYCLINE ON GALLUS DOMESTICUS TRIMESTER 3 Professor J. P. Ellis T.A. Tom Pinard Bryan Dumanski Mike Hale Dean Tower Heather Mammon Joe Hull July 15, 1996...

read more
Cerebral Palsy

The Effects Multiple Births Have on Outcomes of Cerebral Palsy in Infants Cerebral palsy is typically characterized as a disorder caused by injuries to the cerebrum, the part of the brain responsib...

read more
Contraception And Abortion

Contraception and Abortion from the Ancient World to the Renaissance by John Riddle, is a book that tries to make sense of the historical records related to birth control. The historical medical re...

read more
Sex Preselection

Sex Preselection For many years, mankind has wondered how to choose the sex of a child before its birth for which countless myths, folk remedies, and magic potions have been offered as a solution....

read more
Socialized Medicine

Canada s healthcare system has been the envy of many western industrialized countries for years. England s Prime Minister Winston Churchill inspired it in 1948 when he said: The discoveries of hea...

read more
Human Milk Vs. Cow's Milk

Human Milk vs. Cow's Milk TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction Benefits and disadvantages for the infant Breast feeding and the Law Conclusion Bibliography INTRODUCTION Breast feeding in public no...

read more